Reading, Pa. (September 26, 2026) - Alvernia University (2-2, 2-1) knocked through a game winning field goal in the second overtime off the boot of
Kevin Carotenuto to take down Lebanon Valley College (0-4, 0-3), 13-10, Saturday afternoon.
Both the Golden Wolves and the Dutchmen struggled on the offensive side of the ball in a rainy first half as the game headed to the halftime break after a Alvernia field goal with 23 seconds left in the half. After a scoreless second half saw the game head to the overtime period locked at three. The Golden Wolves struck first in the first overtime period when Sawyer Esbenshade connected with James Shaeffer to put the Golden Wolves up 10-3. Lebanon Valley responded with a touchdown on their overtime possession to send it to the second OT tied at ten. The Alvernia defense held strong on the ensuing LVC drive and forced a field goal attempt from 35 yards but it was blocked by Alvernia's A'myre Stewart-Caceres to keep the game tied at ten and gave the Golden Wolves a chance to win it and the Alvernia did just that. After the LVC defense halted the Alvernia offense, the Golden Wolves sent Kevin Carotenuto out there to attempt a 21 yard field goal and Carotenuto split the uprights to send the Golden Wolves into the bye week with a 2-2 overall record and a 2-1 record in the MAC.
How it Happened
- The Dutchmen took the opening kickoff and ripped off a nine play, 51 yard drive that resulted in a 31 yard field goal from LVC's Connor Hazel that put the Dutchmen up 3-0 early.
- Alvernia and Lebanon Valley traded punts back and forth over the next quarter and a half before the Golden Wolves got the ball back with just over five minutes to go in the first half. Alvernia marched down the field and put together a ten play, 61 yard drive that ended in a Carotenuto field goal from 36 yards that tied the game at three heading into the halftime break.
- Both teams struggled to find their way offensively throughout the third quarter and spent the third quarter trading punts back and forth to each other as the game headed to the fourth quarter tied at 3-3.
- Alvernia started the fourth quarter with a nine play drive but it did not result in any points as Carotenuto punted the ball back to the Dutchmen with seven minutes to go in the fourth quarter.
- Lebanon Valley took the ball and went down the field on the Golden Wolves defense and tallied a nine play, 66 yard drive down to the Alvernia eight yard line. On a third and two at the Alvernia eight, LVC ran the ball up the middle but Alvernia's Darrius Whetstone stopped LVC's Osmany Guzman at the line of scrimmage to force a LVC field goal attempt.
- After the two minute timeout, LVC attempted a 25 yard field goal but after a bad snap and hold, LVC's Ellis Gensamer attempted to run but Alvernia's Ta'Jier Burrus was there to stop Gensamer for a 12 yard loss and give the Golden Wolves the ball back with under two minutes to go in the fourth quarter.
- The Golden Wolves got the ball back but were not able to move the ball on offense on the next drive, so, Alvernia looked to Carotenuto to punt and he answered with a 72 yard kick that pinned the Dutchmen inside of their 20 yard line with under a minute to go.
- Alvernia then stopped the Dutchmen on their ensuing drive and got the ball back with under 30 seconds to go in the game and looked to win the game. The Golden Wolves got the ball inside the LVC 20 yard line and gave Carotenuto a chance to win the game with a 36 yard field goal attempt, but Carotenuto's attempt went wide left as time expired to send the game to overtime tied at three.
- The Dutchmen won the coin toss in overtime and elected to play defense first in the overtime period, which resulted in the Golden Wolves finding the endzone in five plays when Esbenshade connected with James Shaeffer to make it a seven point, 10-3 Alvernia lead.
- Lebanon Valley would answer the call on their first overtime drive and found the back of the endzone to tie the game at ten and sent the game into the second overtime.
- It was LVC's turn to go first in the second overtime period and after the Alvernia defense halted the Dutchmen at the Alvernia 18 yard line, the Dutchmen sent out the kicking unit for a 35 yard field goal but the Golden Wolves had other plans. Alvernia's A'myre Stewart-Caceres got his big paw up in the air and in the way of the LVC field goal to deny the Dutchmen and give the Golden Wolves an opportunity to win the game.
- The Golden Wolves then gave Carotenuto the chance to win the game with a 21 yard field goal attempt and he delivered to secure the 13-10 victory for the Golden Wolves, which was the first victory over Lebanon Valley in program history.
Inside the Box Score
- Sawyer Esbenshade completed 14 of 27 passes for a total of 168 yards and one touchdown and did not turn the ball over.
- Zakai Smullen led Alvernia's receiving core with three catches for 71 yards and Adonis Akande followed with six receptions for 50 yards.
- James Shaeffer only caught one ball for two yards, but it was an important touchdown grab in overtime. The catch also came as his first collegiate reception.
- Kashantis Anderson led the Golden Wolves defense with 11 tackles and both Jakob Keglivits and LJ Aldas followed with eight tackles each. Shawn Young added five tackles and 1.5 tackles for a loss.
- Kevin Carotenuto kicked two field goals for the Golden Wolves including the game winning 21 yarder. Carotenuto also tallied five punts for a total of 208 yards, recorded a program record punt of 72 yards and pinned four of his five punts inside the LVC 20 yard line.
Up Next
- The Golden Wolves take the next weekend off for their bye week and are back in action on October 10th when they host Misericrodia at 12:00 PM to kick off a Homecoming and Family Weekend triple header against the Cougars.